Philosophy of Law

Articles

FABRE-MAGNAN, Muriel🕴️

📝The perversion of little moral tales: from trolleys to autonomous vehicles

► Full reference: M. Fabre-Magnan, « La perversion des petits contes moraux : des tramways aux véhicules autonomes » (The perversion of little moral tales: from trolleys to autonomous vehicles), in S. Besson and S. Jubé (eds.), Concerter les civilisations. Mélanges en l’honneur d’Alain Supiot, Le Seuil, 2020, pp. 153-167. - ► Summary: The author seeks to discredit, in their very principle, the “trolley problems”, the small moral case studies born of a 1967 article by Philippa Foot and multiplied into “trolleyology”, which are now invoked to program autonomous vehicles. Beneath their harmless appearance, these scenarios break with the equal dignity of human beings, since they assume that five lives are worth more than one, and they discredit the prohibition of murder. They rest on errors of calculation that judges have always refused to make (The Queen v. Dudley and Stephens, 1884; German Federal Constitutional Court, 15 February 2006; the Touvier case). They confuse principles and exceptions, whereas Law is a mesh of rules and principles that interpretation adjusts without dissolving them. Finally, they blur the boundary between morality and Law and divert attention from the real liabilities, which in the case of autonomous vehicles are not so difficult to establish. Drawing on Paul-Claude Racamier, the author sees in them a technique for disqualifying one’s interlocutor, which ends up erasing all landmarks and doing away with the law. 🦉 This article is available in full text to persons enrolled in Professor Marie-Anne Frison-Roche’s courses.
Couverture – L’Obligation de Compliance

Articles in a JoRC book

SÈVE, René🕴️

📝Les mutations de la souveraineté et l’Obligation de Compliance (Compliance Obligation and changes in Sovereignty and Citizenship), in 🕴️M.-A. Frison-Roche (dir.), 📕L’obligation de Compliance

► Full Reference: R. Sève, “L’Obligation de Compliance et les mutations de la souveraineté et de la citoyenneté” (“Compliance Obligation and changes in Sovereignty and Citizenship”), in M.-A. Frison-Roche (ed.), L’obligation de Compliance, Journal of Regulation & Compliance (JoRC) and Lefebvre-Dalloz, coll. “Régulations & Compliance“, 2025, pp. 97-107. - read the general presentation of the book, L’obligation de Compliance, in which this article is published. - ► This article is written in French. English summary of this contribution (done by the Journal of Regulation & Compliance – JoRC): The contribution describes “the changes in legal philosophy that the notion of Compliance may imply in relation to the modern representation of the State ensuring the effectiveness of laws resulting from the general will, while respecting the fundamental freedoms that constitute the essence of the legal subject” (free translation; the original French text alone is authoritative: « les changements de philosophie du droit que la notion de compliance peut impliquer par rapport à la représentation moderne de l’Etat assurant l’effectivité des lois issues de la volonté générale, dans le respect des libertés fondamentales qui constituent l’essence du sujet de droit. »). The contributor believes that the definition of Compliance is due to authors who “play a role in illuminating and structuring a vast set of ideas and phenomena previously considered in a disjointed manner. For our purposes, this is certainly the case with the theory of Compliance, developed in France by Marie-Anne Frison-Roche in the tradition of great economists (Jean-Jacques Laffont, Jean Tirole), whose first form lay in the Professor’s well-known work on Regulation Law” (free translation; the original French text alone is authoritative: « jouer un rôle d’éclairage et de structuration d’un vaste ensemble d’idées et de phénomènes précédemment envisagés de manière disjointe. Pour ce qui nous occupe, c’est sûrement le cas de la théorie de la compliance, développée en France par Marie-Anne Frison-Roche dans la lignée de grands économistes (Jean-Jacques Laffont, Jean Tirole) et dont la première forme résidait dans les travaux bien connus de la Professeure sur le droit de la régulation. »). Drawing on the Principles of the Law of the American Law Institute, which considers Compliance to be a “set of rules, principles, controls, authorities, offices and practices designed to ensure that an organisation conforms to external and internal norms”, he stresses that Compliance thus appears to be a neutral mechanism aimed at efficiency through a move towards Ex Ante. But he stresses that the novelty lies in the fact that it is aimed “only” at future events, by “refounding” and “monumentalising” the matter through the notion of “Monumental Goals” conceived by Marie-Anne Frison-Roche, giving rise to a new jus commune. Thus, “Compliance is the permanent idea of Law applied to new contexts and challenges” (free translation; the original French text alone is authoritative: « la compliance c’est l’idée permanente du droit appliquée à de nouveaux contextes et défis. »). So it’s not a question of making budget savings, but rather of continuing to apply the philosophy of the Social Contract to complex issues, particularly environmental issues. This renews the place occupied by the Citizen, who appears not only as an individual, as in the classical Greek concept and that of Rousseau, but also through entities such as NGOs, while large companies, because they alone have the means to pursue the Compliance Monumental Goals, would be like “super-citizens”, something that the digital space is beginning to experience, at the risk of the individuals themselves disappearing as a result of “surveillance capitalism”. But in the same way that thinking about the Social Contract is linked to thinking about capitalism, Compliance is part of a logical historical extension, without any fundamental break: “It is the development and complexity of capitalism that force the introduction into private entities of procedural mechanisms of a bureaucratic nature, in order to discipline employees, contain internal and external criticism, and support the managers in place” (free translation; the original French text alone is authoritative: « C’est le développement et la complexité du capitalisme qui forcent à introduire dans les entités privées des mécanismes procéduraux d’essence bureaucratique, pour discipliner les salariés, contenir les critiques internes et externes, soutenir les managers en place »), by forcing them to justify remuneration, benefits, and so on. Furthermore, in the words of the author, “With the Monumental Goals – taking into account the distant, diffuse effects, aggregated across borders, the interests of future generations, of all living beings – we move, so to speak, to an industrial dimension of ethics, which only vast information processing systems make it possible to envisage effectively” (free translation; the original French text alone is authoritative: « Avec les buts monumentaux, – la prise en compte des effets lointains, diffus, agrégés par delà les frontières, de l’intérêt des générations futures, de tous les êtres vivants – , on passe, pour ainsi dire, à une dimension industrielle de l’éthique, que seuls de vastes systèmes de traitement de l’information permettent d’envisager effectivement. »). This is how we can find a division between artificial intelligence and human beings in organisations, particularly companies, or in decision-making processes. In the same way, individual freedom does not disappear with Compliance, because it is precisely one of its Monumental Goals to enable individuals to make choices in a complex environment, particularly in the digital space where the democratic system is now at stake, while technical mechanisms such as early warning will revive the right to civil disobedience, invalidating the complaint of “surveillance capitalism”. The author concludes that the stakes are so high that Compliance, which has already overcome the distinctions between Private and Public Law and between national and international law, must also overcome the distinction between Information and secrecy, particularly in view of cyber-risks, which requires the State to develop and implement non-public Compliance strategies to safeguard the future. - 🦉This article is available in full text to those registered for Professor Marie-Anne Frison-Roche’s courses
Couverture – Compliance Obligation

Articles in a JoRC book

SÈVE, René🕴️

📝Compliance Obligation and changes in Sovereignty and Citizenship, in 🕴️M.-A. Frison-Roche (dir.), 📘Compliance Obligation

► Full Reference: R. Sève, "Compliance Obligation and changes in Sovereignty and Citizenship", in M.-A. Frison-Roche (ed.), Compliance Obligation, Journal of Regulation & Compliance (JoRC) and Bruylant, "Compliance & Regulation" Serie, to be published - 📘read a general presentation of the book, Compliance Obligation, in which this article is published - ► Summary of the article (done by the Journal of Regulation & Compliance – JoRC):  The contribution describes "les changements de philosophie du droit que la notion de compliance peut impliquer par rapport à la représentation moderne de l’Etat assurant l’effectivité des lois issues de la volonté générale, dans le respect des libertés fondamentales qui constituent l’essence du sujet de droit." ("the changes in legal philosophy that the notion of Compliance may imply in relation to the modern representation of the State ensuring the effectiveness of laws resulting from the general will, while respecting the fundamental freedoms that constitute the essence of the subject of law"). The contributor believes that the definition of Compliance is due to authors who « jouer un rôle d’éclairage et de structuration d’un vaste ensemble d’idées et de phénomènes précédemment envisagés de manière disjointe.  Pour ce qui nous occupe, c’est sûrement le cas de la théorie de la compliance, développée en France par Marie-Anne Frison-Roche dans la lignée de grands économistes (Jean-Jacques Laffont, Jean Tirole) et dont la première forme résidait dans les travaux bien connus de la Professeure sur le droit de la régulation. » ( "play a role in illuminating and structuring a vast set of ideas and phenomena previously considered in a disjointed manner.  For our purposes, this is certainly the case with the theory of Compliance, developed in France by Marie-Anne Frison-Roche in the tradition of great economists (Jean-Jacques Laffont, Jean Tirole) and whose first form was in her well-known work on Regulatory Law"). Drawing on the Principles of the Law of the American Law Institute, which considers compliance to be a "set of rules, principles, controls, authorities, offices and practices designed to ensure that an organisation conforms to external and internal norms", he stresses that Compliance thus appears to be a neutral mechanism aimed at efficiency through a move towards Ex Ante. But he stresses that the novelty lies in the fact that it is aimed 'only' at future events, by 'refounding' and 'monumentalising' the matter through the notion of 'monumental goals' conceived by Marie-Anne Frison-Roche, giving rise to a new jus comune. Thus, "la compliance c’est l’idée permanente du droit appliquée à de nouveaux contextes et défis." ("Compliance is the permanent idea of Law applied to new contexts and challenges").  So it's not a question of making budget savings, but rather of continuing to apply the philosophy of the Social Contract to complex issues, particularly environmental issues.  This renews the place occupied by the Citizen, who appears not only as an individual, as in the classical Greek concept and that of Rousseau, but also through entities such as NGOs, while large companies, because they alone have the means to pursue the Compliance Monumental Goals, would be like "super-citizens", something that the digital space is beginning to experience, at the risk of the individuals themselves disappearing as a result of "surveillance capitalism". But in the same way that thinking about the Social Contract is linked to thinking about capitalism, Compliance is part of a logical historical extension, without any fundamental break: "C’est le développement et la complexité du capitalisme qui forcent à introduire dans les entités privées des mécanismes procéduraux d’essence bureaucratique, pour discipliner les salariés, contenir les critiques internes et externes, soutenir les managers en place" ("It is the development and complexity of capitalism that forces us to introduce procedural mechanisms of a bureaucratic nature into private entities, in order to discipline employees, contain internal and external criticism, and support the managers in place") by forcing them to justify remuneration, benefits, and so on. Furthermore, in the words of the author, "Avec les buts monumentaux, – la prise en compte des effets lointains, diffus, agrégés par delà les frontières, de l’intérêt des générations futures, de tous les êtres vivants – ,  on passe, pour ainsi dire, à une dimension industrielle de l’éthique, que seuls de vastes systèmes de traitement de l’information permettent d’envisager effectivement." ("With the Monumental Goals – taking into account the distant, diffuse effects, aggregated across borders, the interests of future generations, of all living beings – we move, so to speak, to an industrial dimension of ethics, which only vast information processing systems can effectively envisage"). This is how we can find a division between artificial intelligence and human beings in organisations, particularly companies, or in decision-making processes. In the same way, individual freedom does not disappear with Compliance, because it is precisely one of its monumental goals to enable individuals to make choices in a complex environment, particularly in the digital space where the democratic system is now at stake, while technical mechanisms such as early warning will revive the right to civil disobedience, invalidating the complaint of "surveillance capitalism". The author concludes that the stakes are so high that Compliance, which has already overcome the distinctions between Private and Public Law and between national and international law, must also overcome the distinction between Information and secrecy, particularly in view of cyber-risks, which requires the State to develop and implement non-public Compliance strategies to safeguard the future. - 🦉This article is available in full text to those registered for Professor Marie-Anne Frison-Roche's courses -

Books

📗La responsabilité